Apple Explains Why Its New Smart Display Goes Dumb the Moment Your iPhone Leaves the Room

Sam Reyes

Based on reporting from Engadget

A Google smart display with a dark, off screen sitting on a wooden table
“Google Home Hub on table” by Y2kcrazyjoker4, via Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Resized · Adapted image shared under the same licence

Apple Explains Why Its New Smart Display Goes Dumb the Moment Your iPhone Leaves the Room

Apple’s reason for why HomeView needs your iPhone or iPad nearby, recognized by its own camera, before it will show your messages or your calendar: privacy. Nothing personal is stored on the display itself, so without your phone close by, HomeView drops back to the basics.

That is a tidy explanation, but it does not change what I would ask of a $299 display: it should do the job on its own. “Capable” is the first of my three C’s, and a shared kitchen display that needs somebody’s phone in the room to actually be useful fails that test before price or looks even come into it.

If I bought one for the kitchen, not having my phone nearby would be a real problem, not a shrug. A display that the whole family checks throughout the day should work the same whether my phone is upstairs, charging, or just left in another room. Apple is free to route the data however it wants for privacy, but that is a design choice, and a $299 price tag should not come with a catch that only shows up after you have already paid it.

Loading comments…